Mystery Darts is a surprise-based experience where you choose your desired dart weight (20g–25g), and we send you a completely random set of premium darts — worth anywhere from £40 to £150 RRP. Each set is brand new and go through a quality check before dispatch ensuring you receive a top grade set of darts every time! You won’t know the brand, design, or value until they arrive, but one thing’s guaranteed: every box brings quality and excitement.

Each box includes a high-quality set of darts — from trusted and premium brands. Each set is brand new, you might get classic designs, limited releases or high-end sets you wouldn’t normally try.

As of June 2025, we have increased our percentage of stock retailing at over £50 by 2% from May. 96% of our stock retails at over £50 and 100% of our stock retails over £40. The aim with the Mystery Dart Box is to ensure variety and uniqueness. Although we strive to ensure we provide the most premium sets in regard to retail cost, we also want to provide flexibility on grip, length & style of the darts we provide which may mean a very small percentage of sets retail lower than £50 but offer that variety.

Every set is a premium set.

Nope — that’s the fun of it! You choose your preferred weight, and we do the rest. Every set is a surprise, but we make sure each box delivers great value and variety.

We get it — surprises can be a gamble. While we don’t offer returns for personal preference, we guarantee quality. If it's the weight that is of concern, we will exchange your darts for a different weight that suits you. If your darts arrive damaged or faulty, we’ll replace them right away.

Orders delivering to the UK typically arrive with Royal Mail within 1–3 working days. International delivery times may vary based on your location and will be confirmed via email, however more often than not it's usually within 4-7 working days.

At checkout upon entering your delivery address you'll see if we currently ship to your address.

For any orders being shipped outside of the UK, a flat-rate shipping fee of £9.99 will apply. We ensure that all customs declarations are completed accurately, including clear item descriptions and the correct tariff (HS) codes. However, please note that any additional charges such as customs duties, VAT, or handling fees imposed by your country’s customs authority are the responsibility of the recipient. These charges are beyond our control and may vary depending on local regulations.

We offer a 14-day return policy, but returns are only accepted under two specific conditions:

1. If the dart weight you selected isn't suitable, and you'd like to exchange for a different weight.

2. If your darts arrive damaged.

Please note: All darts are thoroughly inspected by our team before being packaged and shipped, so any damage in transit is rare — but we’re here to make it right if it happens.

However, light scratches, surface/point marks, and signs of previous use do not count as damage. Our boxes can include pre-loved darts in near-mint condition, as clearly stated on our product pages.

To start a return, contact us at contact@mysterydart.com or via our website contact form. Include your order number, reason for return, and the dart weight you’d like instead (if applicable).

To be eligible for an exchange, the darts must be unused, in their original packaging, and in the same condition they were received. Proof of purchase is also required.

Returns based on personal preferences — such as not liking the look, brand, or style — will not be accepted due to the surprise nature of our product.

Any items sent back without prior approval will not be processed.

You can read our full returns and refunds policy [here].

Each set is either brand new, like new or lightly used and every set goes through a quality check before dispatch.

Some sets may show light marks or minor wear — these are very subtle and do not affect performance.

Because many of our darts are premium models with high retail prices, slight signs of use like small scratches on the barrels or points can occasionally be present. We do our best to keep these minimal and only include darts that meet our quality standards, so you can expect a top-tier set every time.